Managers are often the first stop for employees seeking leave, but they’re the least likely to take it

members-of-team-leaning-on-railing-in-corridor-and-talking

New research shows employees often turn to managers for leave guidance. Yet managers are more likely than non-managers to delay leave or use PTO instead — raising important questions about how employers support the people employees rely on most.

When employees have questions about taking leave, many start with their manager.

Our latest research found that 29% of employees would turn to their manager first for leave information, nearly as many as the 32% who would start with HR or their benefits team.

That makes managers an important part of the leave experience.

But the research reveals an interesting tension: managers appear to understand leave better than other employees, while also being more likely to delay or avoid taking it themselves.

Managers know how leave works but may still hesitate to use it

Managers report greater confidence navigating leave:

  • 58% are very confident they understand their leave benefits, compared with 43% of non-managers
  • 51% are very confident they would know where to start, compared with 33% of non-managers

Yet managers are also more likely to say they have:

  • Delayed or avoided leave: 33% vs. 21% of non-managers
  • Used PTO instead of formal leave: 49% vs. 35% of non-managers

Why is that?

What’s driving those decisions likely differs by manager. But the broader findings suggest that understanding the benefit may not eliminate the practical pressures that come with stepping away.

Findings suggest managers may feel pressure around their responsibilities to their teams. Managers are more likely than non-managers to worry about burdening coworkers when considering leave (24% versus 18%) and more likely to say clear workload coverage would make them more comfortable discussing leave with their own manager (35% versus 24%).

For employers, that raises a bigger question. If managers struggle to take leave themselves, how might that shape the way they support employees who come to them for help?

The first manager conversation matters

Employers see potential friction at this point in the process too. Twenty-six percent say the employee-to-manager handoff is the handoff most likely to create gaps or delays.

That does not mean managers should become leave experts. In fact, the opportunity may be the opposite: make their role simpler and clearer.

What employers can consider

Give managers a clear role
Help managers recognize when a health, caregiving or family situation may warrant additional support, respond appropriately and connect employees quickly with HR or the leave administrator.

Address workload realities
If managers worry about what happens to their teams when someone steps away, benefits education alone may not be enough. Clear coverage plans, cross-training and expectations around how work will be managed can help make leave feel more workable.

Support managers as employees too
Manager training often focuses on helping someone else take leave. Employers may also want to reinforce that managers themselves have access to the same support — and should feel able to use it when they need it.

Better support for managers can mean a better start to leave
Employers already recognize the opportunity. Thirty-nine percent say stronger employee communications would improve absence management, while 27% point to better manager tools and training.

Managers do not need all the answers. But when employees are likely to come to them first, they need to know how to help them find the answers.

And employers may want to make sure managers feel just as supported when they are the ones who need time away.

If managers are the front door to leave, helping them feel comfortable opening that door, for others and for themselves, can be an important part of a better leave experience.

Source: New York Life Group Benefit Solutions Absence Pulse Study, conducted by Morning Consult, September 1–14, 2026, among 2,415 employed adults and 488 HR decision makers. Results have a margin of error of +/- 2–3 percentage points.

New York Life Group Benefit Solutions products and services are provided by Life Insurance Company of North America, New York Life Group Insurance Company of NY, and New York Life Insurance and Annuity Corporation, subsidiaries of New York Life Insurance Company. Life Insurance Company of North America is not authorized in NY and does not conduct business in NY.

SMRU 9206263.1, Exp. 11/02/2029