Life insurance dividends: How they work

Written by: New York Life Editorial Team

Reviewed by: New York Life Compliance Team

Updated: November 19, 2026


Life insurance dividends are an added benefit you may receive if you own a participating whole life insurance policy. Depending on your policy, you could take them as cash, use them to help pay premiums, or put them toward extra coverage.

Dividends aren't guaranteed, and the amount can change from year to year. But understanding what they are and what you can do with them can help you make the most of your policy as your financial needs evolve.

Key takeaways

  • Life insurance dividends are payments some policyowners may receive.
  • The amount you receive depends on a number of factors and your specific policy.
  • Dividends aren't guaranteed. You may receive more or less from one year to the next.
  • Depending on your policy, you can use dividends to buy more coverage, help pay premiums, receive cash, or leave them to earn interest.
Couple reviewing life insurance dividend options together at home.

What are life insurance dividends?

Life insurance dividends are payments eligible policyowners may receive based on a number of factors. They're most commonly associated with participating whole life insurance policies.

  • Participating life insurance allows policyowners to "participate" or share in the insurance company's success through potential dividends.

New York Life is one example of a mutual insurer that offers participating life insurance policies. But not every New York Life policy is eligible for dividends.

 

What makes up a life insurance dividend?

When an insurance company sets its dividend, it makes assumptions about how much it will earn from investments, how much it will pay in claims, and what it will cost to run the business.

Three factors help determine how its actual results compare with those expectations:

  • Investment experience: How much the insurer earns on its investments compared with what it expected.
  • Mortality experience: How many death claims the insurer pays compared with what it anticipated.
  • Expense experience: How much the insurer spends on operating costs compared with its projections.

Each year, after paying claims and expenses, setting aside reserves for future benefits, and maintaining surplus to cushion against unexpected events, the insurance company determines how much of the remaining surplus to distribute to eligible participating policyowners as dividends. This amount is called divisible surplus.

What determines your individual dividend amount?

Your individual dividend amount is based on several factors, rather than a single percentage.

These factors include New York Life’s experience and the dividend scale applicable to the participating product, along with details about your specific policy, such as the type of coverage you own, when it was issued, and its coverage amount.

For example, you and a friend could each own a $250,000 whole life insurance policy but receive different dividends because your policies were issued at different times or have different features.

Is the dividend interest rate the same as your rate of return?

No. A dividend interest rate is one factor an insurer may use when calculating dividends. It isn't your policy's rate of return, and it doesn't tell you exactly how much you'll receive.

It's also different from the interest you may earn if you leave your dividends with the insurer to accumulate. It should be noted that there is no standard practice that companies have to follow in determining their dividend interest rate. On its own, the dividend interest rate should not be used to evaluate policies in terms of cost, benefits, and performance.

 

What can you do with life insurance dividends?

You generally have four ways to use life insurance dividends:

Dividend option

How it works

Take cash

Receive your dividend as a payment you can spend or save.

Reduce your premiums

Apply your dividend toward your insurance premium so you pay less out of pocket.

Accumulate with interest

Leave your dividends with the insurer, where they can earn interest over time.

Buy paid-up additions

Use dividends to purchase additional life insurance coverage, which also builds cash value.

Consider this hypothetical example, if your annual premium is $2,000 and you receive a $500 dividend, you may be able to apply it toward your premium so you pay only $1,500. But if you’d rather increase your death benefit so your loved ones have more money, you might use that $500 to purchase additional coverage instead.

What are paid-up additions?

Paid-up additions are small amounts of extra whole life insurance you can purchase using your dividends. They're called paid-up because you don't have to make additional premium payments to keep that extra coverage in place.

For example, say your policy has a $250,000 death benefit. If you use dividends to buy paid-up additions, your total death benefit could gradually grow beyond $250,000.

These additions also build cash value and may earn dividends of their own, which you can use to purchase even more coverage.

 

Are life insurance dividends guaranteed?

No. Even if your insurance company has paid dividends every year for decades, there's no guarantee you'll receive one in the future.

Participating whole life insurance policies have certain guaranteed benefits, such as a guaranteed death benefit and cash value, provided you meet the policy's requirements. These guarantees are based on the claims-paying ability of the issuer. Dividends are separate from those guarantees.

When you review a policy illustration, you may see projections showing how dividends could increase your coverage or cash value over time. But those projections aren't promises. Your actual dividends could be higher, lower, or zero.

 

Are life insurance dividends taxable?

Life insurance dividends generally aren't taxable because the IRS typically treats them as a return of premiums you've already paid.

But there are two common exceptions where you could owe taxes:

  • Your dividends exceed your remaining tax basis. If you've already recovered the amount you paid into the policy tax-free, additional dividends may be taxable.
  • You leave dividends with your insurer to earn interest. The interest you earn is generally taxable, even if the dividends themselves aren't.1

For example, say you receive a $500 dividend and leave it with your insurer. If that money earns $20 in interest, the $20 is generally taxable income.

The tax treatment can get more complicated if you've taken withdrawals or loans against your policy, so check with a tax professional if you're unsure how the rules apply to you.

 

How does New York Life pay dividends?

New York Life is a mutual insurance company, meaning it's owned by its policyowners rather than outside shareholders. That gives eligible participating policyowners an opportunity to share in the company's success through dividends.

New York Life has paid dividends to eligible participating policyowners every year since 1854. Although that history doesn't guarantee future payments, it reflects the company's longstanding commitment to sharing its success with policyowners.

And those dividends can serve different purposes as your life changes. You might use them to purchase additional coverage while raising a family, then apply them toward premiums later in life when you're looking to keep expenses down.

When New York Life performs well, eligible policyowners may benefit in ways that support their own financial goals.

 

How can I review or change my dividend option?

If you already have a participating whole life insurance policy, check your policy documents or annual statement to see how you’re currently using your dividends.

If you'd like to make a change, contact your New York Life financial professional to review the options available under your policy. For example, you may be able to switch from receiving dividends as cash to using them to purchase additional coverage.

Your financial professional can also help you understand how a change could affect your premiums, cash value, or death benefit over time.

 

Frequently asked questions

Life insurance dividends are typically declared annually, although payment timing depends on your insurer and policy. The amount you receive may change from year to year.

If your dividend is large enough, you may be able to use it to cover your full premium. That said, always be prepared to pay your premiums yourself if future dividends fall short or don’t happen. Because dividends aren't guaranteed, you shouldn't rely on them to cover your premiums.

Your dividend could increase, decrease, or remain the same based on the insurance company’s investment experience, mortality or claims experience, expenses, other financial results, and the dividend scale applicable to your policy. Even if the insurer announces a larger total dividend payout, your specific dividend may not increase because it also depends on factors specific to your policy.

 

Related Articles

Explore what whole life insurance can do for you.

Explore how whole life insurance works, or talk with a New York Life financial professional about whether it fits your needs.

1Internal Revenue Service. “Life Insurance & Disability Insurance Proceeds.” Accessed October 29, 2026.

Neither New York Life Insurance Company(NY,NY), nor its agents, provides tax, legal, or accounting advice. Please consult your own tax, legal, or accounting professional before making any decisions.

As noted throughout the article, dividends are not guaranteed.