VP, NYL and CEO, Nautilus Group
There are so many things in our lives right now that are uncertain—the potential changes to federal tax laws, the duration of the global pandemic and how that may affect our economy. It’s difficult to know what to expect as you plan for your financial future.
But here’s one thing that is certain: State-level estate or inheritance taxes can be imposed on your estate, and while these regulations and exemptions vary between jurisdictions, this is something you definitely can plan for.
To help you do that, my team at The Nautilus Group compiled the following list of little known facts about state estate taxes.
Seventeen states and the District of Columbia currently impose some type of state-level estate tax or inheritance tax.1 To many individuals, the terms "estate tax" and "inheritance tax" may seem interchangeable as they both imply a death-related tax. However, a true estate tax is a tax on the right to pass property onto others and is usually payable by the decedent’s estate. A true inheritance tax, in contrast, is a tax on a beneficiary’s right to receive property and is usually imposed on the beneficiary.
Another key distinction between the two taxes is that the estate tax rate is generally the same regardless of who the recipient of the property may be. An inheritance tax rate tends to vary depending on the relation of the beneficiary to the decedent. Generally, transfers to "close relatives", such as children, may escape inheritance taxes or are taxed at a preferential rate while transfers to more “distant” relatives, such as nieces and nephews or cousins, may be subject to higher rates.
In addition to imposing an estate tax on decedents domiciled2 in the state, states with an estate tax regime may impose an estate tax on the real property or tangible property of "nonresidents" that is physically in the state. Other property with a connection to the state may be subject to state death taxes as well. For example, a state’s estate tax laws may tax certain interests in entities which own realty in the state, interests in certain entities taxed as partnerships or S corporations that own closely held businesses in the state, etc. Specific state law provisions regarding what may be taxable vary widely.
In addition to the surprise tax-hit, nonresidents may only qualify for a reduced estate tax exemption amount as compared to residents of the state.
While federal estate taxes affect only a small group of taxpayers, state estate taxes have significantly lower exemptions and are a concern for a much wider range of individuals. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 doubled the federal estate tax exemption amount to $10 million. Adjusted for inflation, the exemption amount in 2020 is $11.58 million per spouse.3 In contrast, state estate tax exemption amounts can be as low as $1 million in Massachusetts or Oregon, $2,193,000 in Washington, $3 million in Minnesota or $4 million in Illinois. While some states have indexed their estate tax exemption for inflation, others have not.
The highest marginal federal estate tax rate is 40%, applicable to taxable amounts in excess of $1 million. State estate tax rates are typically much lower. The highest marginal state estate tax rate may be in the 16% to 20% range, or lower, depending on the state. While not all states offer graduated rates, the highest tax bracket is often not reached until taxable amounts exceed $9-$10 million.
The federal estate tax exemption is "portable"—in other words, a decedent’s unused federal estate tax exemption may be utilized by the surviving spouse in certain circumstances. If the decedent passes $1 million to his children upon death and all other assets pass to the surviving spouse, the surviving spouse might be able to utilize the decedent’s remaining $10.48 million exemption in addition to his or her own exemption. Portability may allow a surviving spouse to take advantage of his/her deceased spouse’s unused exemption without traditional “A-B” trust planning.
A-B trust planning involves the creation and funding of a "bypass trust" at the first death to utilize the decedent’s exemption and channeling remaining assets to the survivor to defer estate taxes until the second death.
Many states that impose a state estate tax do not currently allow for portability of an individual’s state estate tax exemption amount. As a result, a bypass trust may be required to utilize the predeceased spouse’s state exemption amount, or it may be wasted and the family’s state estate taxes will unnecessarily increase at the survivor’s death. In some states, it also may be permissible to create a separate "state QTIP trust" which may defer state estate taxes until the surviving spouse’s death and also utilize the decedent’s exemption for federal estate tax purposes. (Note that some states do not permit a separate state-QTIP election).
For federal tax purposes, the gift and estate tax exemptions have been unified—with a combined lifetime exemption of $11.58 million (in 2020). Lifetime gifts that utilize the exemption reduce the amount of exemption that remains available at death. This may not be the case with state estate taxes4. In several—but not all—states with a state estate or inheritance tax regime, it may be possible to reduce or avoid state estate or inheritance tax by making lifetime gifts. Those contemplating lifetime gifts should be mindful that rules may be in place that penalize the use of “deathbed” gifts to avoid the estate or inheritance tax and a look-back period may apply. Additionally, certain states may take into account lifetime gifts for filing thresholds for estate taxes.
State estate, inheritance and gift tax laws vary greatly by state and change frequently. Clients should always consult with a CPA, tax attorney or estate planning attorney regarding specific state death taxes that may be applicable to them and state estate, gift or inheritance tax planning.